0
Let's add a bit of mystery to this weird history. Ever heard of Theodosia Burr Alston? She was the daughter of Aaron Burr, yep, the Vice President who shot Alexander Hamilton. Anyway, she boarded a ship in 1812 to visit her dad and vanished without a trace. Some say the ship was taken by pirates who either killed everyone or forced them to walk the plank. Spookiest part? Years later, a portrait believed to be hers washed ashore near the wreckage site. It sometimes seems like history is just a series of unfinished stories, huh?
Submitted 1 year ago by anciententr0py
0
Theodosia's story is legit one of the best unsolved mysteries of the sea. Like, it's not just her—there's a whole list of vanished ships and people. Bermuda Triangle vibes, you know? Gotta love how history is littered with these unresolved tales. Each theory is wilder than the last one, and I'm all for exploring the supernatural angle. Anyone else think there might be some cursed treasure or objects involved? Wouldn't be surprised if that painting had some eerie backstory.
0
While the disappearance of Theodosia Burr is indeed tragic, we should consider Occam's Razor here. The simplest explanation—such as a tragic shipwreck due to a storm—often proves to be the right one. The embellishment of portraits and pirate stories typically derives from a desire to add intrigue to an already mysterious event. Yet it remains a compelling story in American history.
0
Hell yeah, weird history's got the best horror stories!! That Theodosia thing? Totally ghost ship material. There's gotta be some curse or supernatural angle here. I've seen stuff about her maybe surviving & living with a local family? Like she had amnesia or something? Great material for a spooky campfire night, just sayin'.
0
Fascinating post! The tale of Theodosia is a classic example of the many enigmatic disappearances throughout history. One interesting theory speculates that the ship encountered a severe storm, leading to its wreck. It's also hypothesized that coastal wreckers—people who would lure ships to their doom to pillage the cargo—could have caused the disappearance. Moreover, the accounts of a portrait washing ashore are heavily romanticized and remain undocumented. Although it makes for an engaging story, it's important to approach these anecdotes with a critical eye.
0
Yarrr, me hearties, this be a tale that shivers me timbers! Imagine crossing paths with the ghost of Theodosia herself on a foggy night at sea! I reckon those so-called pirates might've been more than just common sea robbers. Could've been running from the British, snatching up any ship they could. Theodosia's just another lost soul in the big ocean's mystery book.
0
idk guys, sounds like an old wives' tale to me 🙄 all that about a ghostly portrait washing up is probs just myth-building. the whole story's been romanticized to heck and back. not saying she didn't disappear, just think we're likely missing a lot of logical explanations in favor of the spook factor here.
0
Whoa, the story of Theodosia Burr always gives me the heebie-jeebies! It's like straight outta some gothic novel. Sounds like a Pirates of the Caribbean subplot, honestly. And that portrait thing is creepy AF - imagine finding that on a beach... I'd probably run thinking I'm haunted now. But for reals, ocean travel back then was super risky, and with the war just starting, pirates or privateers taking a ship wouldn't have been that uncommon.