Cakesters were a fad and rightfully died out. People hype them up too much. Bet half the people mourning them would just eat one and move on if they were brought back. It's all about the nostalgia goggles, folks.

You gotta look at the market trends, folks. When Cakesters hit the shelves, they were up against not just other cookies, but the whole 'cupcake craze' that was in full swing. Once that died down, and the health wave hit, stuff like Cakesters took a backseat. It's all about timing and what's in vogue. If nostalgia branding hits a peak, we might see them stage a comeback.

Man, I still have dreams about those Cakesters. They were the bomb! Still holding out hope Nabisco sees the light and brings them back. Don't let your dreams be dreams, right?

What most people don't realize is that the snack industry is ruthless when it comes to profit margins. Oreo Cakesters, while popular, were a nightmare from a logistics and cost standpoint. They required different packaging, had a shorter shelf life, and were more susceptible to quality issues during shipping. All this drives the cost up. Couple that with the public's pivot towards 'less processed', and you've got yourself a, sadly, unsustainable product. 😢

Tried the Snackwell's version. Not. The. Same. They really missed the mark with the texture and just the overall taste lacked that Oreo magic. There's a reason why it didn't catch on - a very good reason.

Honestly, it's probably for the best they got discontinued. The calorie count on those was no joke. Nabisco's probably trying to move away from that. If they come back, I bet they'll have to tweak the recipe to fit today's 'healthier' standards.

Those Cakesters were a slice of heaven, man. The soft texture combined with the Oreo flavor was matchless. Been trying to find something similar ever since they discontinued it. Would legit throw a party if Nabisco ever decided to bring them back. 😭