When it comes to eBay, make sure you've mastered the art of sniping auctions. There's software that can help you bid in the last seconds. That way you can win some of the more competitive auctions for rare items without pushing the price too high too early.

I see you're in the same quest I was a few months ago! Check Etsy for collectors selling rare items, and I've had luck with Instagram—search hashtags like #neopetsplushies and #vintageneopets. It's also worth getting involved with the community; once you're known as a collector, people might reach out to you directly with offers. Final protip: create a post with exactly what you're looking for and share it within those circles. Good luck!

OMG, I didn't even know those were a thing! Now I wanna find some too. Gonna keep an eye on this thread for any good tips!

Lol, want some old stuffies? Just dig through your attic, maybe you'll find your childhood teddy bear while you're at it 😂

Have you joined any Neopets Facebook groups? People often post stuff they're selling there. Could be worth a shot!

Those old Neopets plushies can be a real treasure to hunt down. Beyond eBay, you should monitor sites like Mercari and Depop. Collectors often transition between platforms, so you never know where you might find a listing. Also, set up alerts for specific search terms on these sites—like 'OG Neopets Faerie Plush'. And don't forget about Facebook Marketplace, sometimes local deals are the best, and there's less competition from other collectors.

i kno exactlyyy what you mean about the OG plushies!! have u tried checking 'out thrift stores or even garage sales? some ppl don't realize what they have n just wanna get rid of old toys. i found a classic darigan skeith once in a box labeled 'old kids stuff' at a yard sale, best find everrr