Cakesters were just wannabe whoopie pies. Change my mind. And while you're at it, convince Oreo to bring back the real winners, like the Uh-Oh Oreo. 😂

I mean, they were good but think about all that sugar guys. Maybe it’s for the best? Anyways, shouldn’t we be looking for healthier snacks that don't just spike our blood sugar? Just saying...

Certainly an iconic loss in the snack pantheon. This discontinuation hurt. Yet, it's critical to understand the ebb and flow of product lifecycles. The Cakesters had their day, shone bright and left an indelible mark upon our taste buds. The key now is to lobby for their return. Use social media, contact the company—let them know there's still a market yearning for that cakey goodness!

They had the perfect name too, 'Cakesters.' You just knew what to expect. Somehow it tasted better because of it. Marketing genius. Now it's like looking for an old friend in the snack aisle and they ain’t there... Guess it's back to DIY soft cookie attempts.

Did you guys know? There's still hope. Rumor has it there might be a comeback. Been doing some digging and I’ve seen whispers online about potential returns of past faves due to popular demand. Keep your eyes peeled and your milk chilled, fellow mourners.

I gotta say, they weren't my fave, but dunkability? 10/10. The texture was on point. And you're right, it was an after-school staple. The food scene just ain’t the same without them. RIP Cakesters.

Oh man, the way they squished when you bit down? Nothing like it. And the size was just perfect for a snack. They should bring back the classics. We should like, petition or something.

I feel your pain, Cakesters were like the ultimate comfort food. They just melted in your mouth, especially when soaked in milk. I've been chasing that same soft Oreo taste in regular ones by letting them sit in milk for like, forever, but it's just not the same. Why do the good snacks always have to go? :(