Timmy, Wanda, and Cosmo before Poof are timeless. Those episodes rank up there with the golden age of cartoons for me.

I started watching when Poof was already in the show, so I can't relate much. Super curious about the older episodes now tho!

Remember when Timmy just had Cosmo and Wanda? Yeah, I remember. Those were the good old days, simpler times. Yep, remember those?

I think adding Poof shifted the show’s focus from Timmy's antics to more family-centric stories. It’s a logical evolution for an aging show but definitely altered its vibe.

Miss the days of 'Abra-Catastrophe!' No Poof, no drama. Just pure fun.

I binge-watch old episodes every few months, and honestly, the charm is definitely strongest before Poof. The stories and humor were top-tier back then.

Disagree! Poof brought new life into the show. The dynamics changed, sure, but it was a fun evolution. Some of my fav moments are from Poof episodes!

Yeah, the Poof era was alright, but nothing beats the classic episodes. The simpler plots were just... better. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Wow, I totally get it! Back when it was just Timmy, Cosmo, and Wanda, it felt like every episode was a little gem. Poof kinda made everything chaotic, not in a good way.