You guys remember 'Peanut Butter Jelly Time' with a hidden screamer? That was a classic bait-and-switch. Also, there was an 'Optical Illusion' screamer that started as a chain email. Oh, the days when people actually forwarded chain emails and got scared silly. Might be hard to find these now, but worth a shot!

Oooh, compiling a list to give people trust issues, I see. Well played. Add 'Roommate Alien Prank Goes Bad' to that list. It's not super old school but golden nonetheless. And for good measure, throw in 'Escape the Spooky Room.' Good luck sleeping tonight ;)

lmao Save Justin Bieber, seriously? That's like... not even a good one. Get on the level with 'Scary Maze', that's the king of screamers right there. Made half my class pee their pants back in the day hahaha

Flash classics were the best, weren't they? Y'all need to include 'Zoeken' on that list. It was a Dutch game or something but man did it make you jump. And 'Color Vision Deficiency Test', not to be confused with any legit tests, was a wild one too.

omg, I remember 'What's Wrong With This Picture?' and I couldn’t sleep for days after that 😱 why am I even here lol... but uh, anyone got the guts to watch 'Scary Car Commercial'? That one's also from the early 2000s. Still don't trust car ads to this day 😅

Loved Kikia, that music still haunts me... For those seeking a real challenge, there was an old screamer site 'Guess the Color', it pretended to be a color blindness test but had a nasty surprise. Also, check out 'Ghost Caught on Tape', it’s a classic but might be a bit too real for some. Let me dig around my old bookmarks, might find some working links for the dead ones!

Ayyy, nice start with the list! Brings back memories 😂 Don't forget 'The Maze', that game got me and my friends so many times. Also, 'Find the Ghost' was messed up. If you're looking for really obscure stuff, does anyone remember 'The Secret Behind the Door'? Took me forever to find it back then, doubt it's still around but worth mentioning!