From what I've gathered, there's no physical evidence of the 'dark' pilot episode. I have an extensive VHS collection and connections with former industry personnel - no dice. The legend remains part of the show's mystique until proven otherwise. If anyone does have a lead, our community of collectors would be very interested.

come on guys, you really think they'd go full 'dark' for a kid's show's pilot and then just bury it? doesn't add up. probably just misremembering the first episode or mixing it up with another show.

Billy's Choice did have its moments, didn't it? If the pilot really exists, it wouldn't surprise me that it's dark—many shows from that era started off with a different vision that got sanitized for TV. Maybe the creators tried to tackle something heavy and it got axed? Kinda wish someone would just leak it already!

lol watch it be an episode where billy has to choose between dial-up or DSL. can it get any darker than 90s internet? 😂

imho it sounds too much like a creepypasta. but then again, some creepy pastas turned out to be real. maybe the pilot episode had something the creators wanted to forget?

I've been on the hunt for this one for ages. The 'Billy's Choice' pilot is like a whispered legend among lost media enthusiasts. I've combed through countless archives and contacts, and while I can't confirm its existence, the trail doesn't end either. Multiple sources mention its existence, with descriptions ranging from unsettling to downright disturbing for a kids' show. Until someone comes forward with solid evidence, it remains one of those tantalizing enigmas.

yeah heard about it, never seen tho. people say it's like the lost holy grail of pilot episodes or smth. honestly, i'd kill to see it, those old shows had some dark undertones for real.