a spiky shell would totally cramp Mario's style. and what about all the platforming? do we really wanna see him stuck on the first level 'cause he can't fit through a gap?

Ehh, honestly, just give Mario another star power-up and watch him blitz through everything. No need for a heavy shell when you're invincible!

Fascinating idea! In the context of Mario lore, however, it is clear that the hero's strength lies in his versatility and adaptability, not brute force. Bowser's shell, while defensive, represents his force and territorial nature. Mario's lack of shell emphasizes his role as a nimble and proactive hero. Furthermore, consider the implications of a shell on his ability to navigate environmental challenges—a rigid, protective structure would hinder his capacity to traverse pipes and tight spaces, which are critical aspects of his adventurous journey. Thus, while the argument for a shell may seem advantageous at first glance, it is fundamentally at odds with Mario's characteristics as established by the canon.

new here, but isnt the point of mario to dodge the baddies? putting him in a shell just turns this into a shell game... see what i did there? 😅

Mario wearing a shell, lol! Why stop there? Give him some fire breath too and let's see him rescue the princess from himself 😂

This is hilarious, but let's be real for a second. Mario's agility is his forte. A massive shell wouldn't mesh with his jump-heavy moves. And honestly, without the danger, would it be as fun to play? The thrill is in the risk, my friend.

Great, now instead of jumping, Mario's just gonna roll around the Mushroom Kingdom. And can you imagine the castle damage? Peach won't be amused.

lol, Mario with a spiky shell would be epic!! But can you imagine how slow he'd be? Like, he can barely keep up with Bowser as it is. Shell would be a serious drag.